Tuesday, September 18, 2007

More on The Roots of Jewish Self Hatred

I have thought more about Jewish self hatred, and I feel that this sums up the roots of this problem best.


I started to read The Jewish State by Yoram Hazony, and I feel it misses most of the point of where the problem of "post-zionism" and Jewish self hatred stems from. I believe that the essence of the problem can be summed up by the way the Islamists describe Israel as little Satan.

Jewish self hatred is not limited to the Jews; Western self hate is at an all time high, and I hope to visit Eurodhimmiland this winter just to see the Louvre and large parts of Paris prior to it being taken over by Islamists. What does Western self-hate and Jewish Israeli self-hate have in common? Answer: they both derive from a hatred of capitalism and the American way.

Israel was formed upon a "Labour-Zionist" ideal, and I view this, i.e., its socialist roots, as the core of the problem. Every year that Israel moves away from these socialist roots, it has a greater and greater chance of success against its internal and external enemies.

Socialism is a form of nihilism, and it is directly inapposite to an idea of Judaism. True socialism cannot succeed as long as Jews remain Jewish. The USSR knew this, witness their extensive antisemitism. Karl Marx knew this, see On the Jewish Question.

And so Israel did perform genuine bad things against its religious populations early on in its statehood. I would argue this is the result of the nihilistic orientation of its Founders. The way the Mizrahi, for instance, were treated by the 'liberal' socialist Zionist elite is deplorable.

But this all is the result of an anti-Jewish attitude exhibited by the founders of Israel. This anti-Jewish attitude stems from socialism, which is also anti-Christian and anti-nationalistic. To the extent that the West has been gripped by suicidal tenancies, this is why. (NOTE: the founders were pro-Jewish ethnicity, but antagonistic towards the Jewish religion. Ben Gurion himself was an atheist.)

Israel's self hate did not materialize out of thin blue air. The self hatred in Israel is minimal in comparison to what is in Eurodhimmiland and the US, aka, "Big Satan," from whence the self-hating philosophy has its roots. This self hatred is even evident in India, whereby the communist parties seek total abdication of India's might to the Islamists. (Remember that communists and Islamists are aligned.)

The future of Israel and the West rests with the rejection of nihilism and the embrace of an alternative, non-suicidal philosophy. Judaism is one such alternative, but is by no means the only one.

2 comments:

PM said...

I think, the problem lies in todays propaganda... they are brainwashing peoples to hate their own culture.. and its working. and ur question rises because of distinction u made between left, right, communist, islamist and so on... but world is grey, not black & white...

lets recheck a few side...we only discuss Nationalist side to Nazis, but Nazi is a abbrivative of National-Socialist. As per Hitlers speech on May 1, 1927.. his words were

"We are socialists, we are enemies of today's capitalistic economic system for the exploitation of the economically weak, with its unfair salaries, with its unseemly evaluation of a human being according to wealth and property instead of responsibility and performance"

now comes the difference... Communist evil was clear, when people came under communists execution, especially during global depression, communist ordered murder of all those farmers, who protested against state.. that had taken control over their lands...

Hitler also got the wave, and his answer to the speech was a well drafted speech... which shows his communist/socialist policies... but he make a real distinction in his speech... he added...
"Nazism has nothing to do with Marxian Socialism, because Marxism is anti-property; true Socialism is not."

anyways Hitler also added...
"I absolutely insist on protecting private property... we must encourage private initiative", but it was more a crispy layer...

Indeed Hitler took over control of nearly all means of production like a good Socialist or Communist would. He did not nationalize all assets of production like what other socialist did. The nominal ownership was left in private hands. But the substance of ownership passed to the state.

beside this, you only need to check campaign mainfesto of Nazi, you will find it similar to todays left mainfesto...

anyways now come to the real part...

The Goal of nazis was world domination, under a motto ... "Ein volk, ein f├╝hrer"(one race, one king).. something which is far more closer to communist as well as islamofacist ideology... don't forget the reason, why stalin attacked tito (with motto, one community, one leader)... and with islamist its one kaliph, one Islam, and one Arab supremacy....

The concept of political correctness, or multiculturalism and so on... they all are just political terms... let me know, how much political correct occur's from those selfhater's... they only time it spring out is mainly to defend Islam.. not any other religion...

anyways, now lets see the Islamic view... Yes it is more liberal then Nazi policies... you can live in state with your private property... but you need to pay tax for the gas you breath... especially if you are Non-Muslim...

and at last, Nazis propaganda was better in quality, if one compare against communist. Islamist propaganda reaches its height... where even Goppels will shy... becasue Islamist invest heavily in enemies media... and use enemies resources as propaganda...

so dont worry, its only introduction... Hitler got nominated for nobel prize before war due to propoganda, and arrafat (Islamist) earned nobel prize with propoganda... so u can compare it here well...

Daniel said...

pm,
good point. In germany today, nazism is considered a left wing movement. national as opposed to international socialism(bolshevism). In the US its unfortuneately taught as a right wing movement.
Furthermore, since the mensheviks split from the bolsheviks because they wanted to maintain some autonomy as jewish communists, and sice the second aliya was dominated by mensheviks, one can say that the secular leftist oof Israel are the true judeo-nazis!